Writing music for Yourself vs for Sync

Depending on whether the end goal is still to add that next song to an album or pitch it for a movie, the beginning steps of the writing process may vary. Here are some key differences on writing for yourself vs. writing for sync placements.

by AARON TRUMM of SoundFly

One of the best ways to make money as a musician is through sync (ie: licensing). Dive into that world, however, and you’ll quickly discover there’s a vast difference between that business and the traditional “artist” model.

The artist model is the one your grandma thinks of when you say you’re a musician. You play gigs, you make a record, you get famous, you make money in mysterious ways, and when asked what you do you say, “I’m a rock star.”

Famous artists get songs licensed all the time — for movies, TV shows, ads, video games, you name it. Not so famous artists get licenses too. But for real licensing G’s, licensing isn’t a one-off occurrence where a popular song gets used for its novelty. In this world, the number one goal is landing placements, and that game is very different from the rock star game.

Here, we’re going to talk about the differences, the crossovers, and what you need to be aware of if you’re attempting to do both.

Different Goal = Different Sound

In any art, the end-use determines a lot about how you go about creating. If you’re making an image intended to hang on a large wall, you might use a big canvas, big brush strokes, and so on. An image intended as an album cover needs a different strategy. It has to fit in a 5” x 5” space, include pertinent info, etc.

Similarly, sync music serves a different purpose and is listened to in a different context than your average radio hit. Some of the big considerations:

• Sync music is either placed under dialog or supports a montage. If under dialog, lyrics might need to be more sparse or non-existent. In both cases, lyrics that convey a general feeling rather than painting specific pictures work better. “Brand new day” or “feeling lost,” rather than “I woke up, bought a pizza from a red truck and wandered 6th street til the sun came up.” This is usually called “universal lyrics.”
• Sync music needs easy “edit points.” Instead of a flowing, uncuttable transition from verse to chorus, for example, try a break down. Give editors a place they can cut in easily.
• Topics may be different in sync music, especially where ads are concerned. If you take a gander at the Billboard Top 40 any week of any year, you’ll be hard pressed to find songs that aren’t romantic love songs. In sync, though, romantic love songs are rare. Especially when it comes to ads, a variety of more universal topics dominate – stuff like “that good good feeling” or “I do it my way.” In TV and Film, romantic love may come up, but as mentioned above, topics are vaguer, so they’ll fit more situations.
• Emulating bigger artists can get you a long way in sync. It’s a death nell for an “original” artist. Many briefs mention some particular song. “Something similar to…” actually means “exactly like, without actually plagiarizing.” If you’re good at emulating, you’ve got a leg up in sync. Writing for artist work calls for more originality, even when you’re trying to fit into a genre.
• Sync work generally requires more range than writing for a single act. Sync-focused writers and producers are called upon to create moods; suspense, action, sexy, reflection, celebration, melancholy, etc. Or they may be asked to create specific genres — jazz or rock or hip-hop. Sometimes it’s more a matter of function — dramedy cues or trailer music, for example. Artist music needs enough variety to stay interesting, staying in basic lane is preferable for a given act.

+ Read more on Flypaper: “Know Your Rights: A Simple Guide to Digital Royalties.”

Putting Them Together

For artists whose dream is to sell out stadiums, but who need to make money in the mean time, licensing is an attractive proposition. Similarly, for sync-focused artists, releasing music on streaming services and creating an “act” is a smart way to maximize income and opportunities.

But people often get confused about how to do this. Let’s go over two areas to consider here: business and art. 

We’ll tackle art first.

The Art Side of Combining Sync and Artist Work

As we said, how you go about making music can be wildly different if sync is your goal vs. radio or streaming hits and other artist-focused goals. So, if you want to do both, you’ve got one big decision to make: do I make two separate kinds of music, or do I try to make music that will work in both arenas?

The latter can be tricky, and a lot depends on your genre. If you’re an avant-garde death metal band known for specific imagery and a lot of cussing, those songs may not get a lot of licenses. On the other hand, if you’ve been making tons of sync-focused music in a hundred different genres, creating one act around all that disparate material could be hard.

But, if you’re an artist already bent toward upbeat, universal lyrics and your sound fits what’s popular in licensing right now, maybe all you have to do is shift your arrangements a bit and write some sync songs in your style.

So, you’ll need to evaluate your stuff. Does your act naturally lean toward what works for licensing, or would it work to change it a bit? For sync artists, does your catalog have enough of one genre that you could create a persona around that?

Next (and this is huge), evaluate the time you have. It’s all well and good to be inspired to do 20 trailer tracks and shop them around while also touring and making your third electronic noise band record. But, do you really have time for all that?

The Business Side of Combining Sync and Artist Work

This seems to be confusing to a lot of people, so let’s clear one thing up. A question that gets asked all the time is:

“If I sign my song to a licensing library, does mean I can’t put it on Spotify?”

NO. Signing with a licensing library only gives them the right to shop and license your material, probably taking a commission. This is a separate set of rights than distribution rights. You still own your material, so even if you’ve signed on with an exclusive licensing company, you still retain the right to release music to the public.

• Here’s the exception: If your licensing company is also a label, and your deal includes handing over the right to release, precluding you from self-release, then you can’t (obviously).
• Here’s how you know: Read the contract. Tedious, yes, but necessary. You can also ask the company what you can and cannot do under the terms of the contract.

What this means is that the business side of doing both artist work and sync work isn’t all that complicated. You own your songs and your recordings, unless you’ve signed those rights away. To reiterate, allowing any company to shop and license songs on your behalf does not sign away your rights. It only authorizes them to take action to secure licensing placements on your behalf.

There’s a lot to this stuff, so if you’re new, start with my more comprehensive piece on songs and recordings and business, “What the Hell Are Master Rights?” And to get a real understanding of the ins and outs of the business of licensing, sit down with a book like The New and Complete Business of Licensing: The Essential Guide to Monetizing Intellectual Property.

But to find out once and for all how all types of streaming and sales royalties work — and how to collect the money you deserve — definitely check out Soundfly’s free course instructed by Ari Herstand, How to Get All the Royalties You Never Knew Existed.

Either Way, Get to Work

Licensing music is a great way to make a living in music, and it doesn’t require fame or any special kind of luck. But being an artist, out in front and on stage, doing your own thing is super compelling, too.

So whatever you do, stop reading about it now and get to work writing!