Labels Mull Pulling All Music Videos From YouTube
Record labels are considering pulling all music videos off YouTube because its become the free music service of choice for so many. They're are upset over the lack of revenue and the anemic pace of Google's efforts to add paid tiers and better monetize the service.
By Bobby Oswinski of Music 3.0.
In a dispute that's reminiscent of what happened with MTV in the 1980s, the 3 major labels are considering removing videos of their most prominent artists from YouTube, according to various reports.
Out of all streaming sources, YouTube pays the lowest royalty rate and the labels are looking for what they consider a more fair split (it's currently 55% labels/45% YouTube).
The platform has long been a source of frustration for the majors, since YouTube has a firm grip on the ad policy, sales channel and monetization and the labels have very little say.
Perhaps throwing fuel on the fire, YouTube recently announced that the number of advertisers increased by 40% last year, with the average spend up more than 100% over a year ago. What's more, YouTube's revenue was over $6.6 billion last year, but the music industry only saw about $150 million of that, according to the RIAA. YouTube disputes that figure and states that it's really "in the billions," although no hard figures are given.
While the majors are quietly increasing their support of other platforms like Vessel and Snapchat, they're being careful about removing support from YouTube just yet. The platform is still where most people consume music (especially new music), and it still provides a significant source of income.
Plus, with YouTube's Music Key subscription service around the corner, that income could possibly increase even more, although most top level label execs are skeptical.
However it shakes out, this bears watching.
I hope all record labels will pull their music videos off of YouTube. In this case, there will be much more space for us independent artists to promote our music.
The labels – majors and indies – absolutely should pull their music off YouTube. But it requires a concerted effort. If all (or most) labels cut off the content supply, and demand full block of illicit uploads of their material, YouTube would become just a site for cat videos, or they would have to negotiate better terms.
Far from truth. There is too much free quality music these days on YouTube generated by independent artists (really independent artists that have never signed a contract with a record label).
Nowadays, Google couldn’t care less whether the record labels pull their music videos off of YouTube or not.