Universal Music Takes Down Fun Mashup Of Taylor Swift’s ‘Shake It Off’ And A 1989 Aerobics Video
[UPDATED] This article originally appeared on TechDirt.com
Last year, when Daft Punk released it's super popular single "Get Lucky" the first time I actually heard it was when someone I know linked to a fantastic video of the song put over a danceline from Soul Train. It's pretty amazing how well it works. You can see it here:
That video has about 4.5 million views. Not bad.
As you may have heard, Taylor Swift recently came out with a new album, "1989," and she's at war with Spotify over it and making some statements about streaming royalties and such (which we've mostly been avoiding covering because this fight has gone on long enough already and it's silly and mostly misleading).
However, in the last day or so, someone tried to do the equivalent of the Soul Train/Get Luckyvideo above with Swift's song "Shake it Off." – (*that someone was Charlie Koncher). (*He) matched the song to an aerobics competition video from (amusingly) 1989 — and it worked quite well. It got lots of attention with the Huffington Post and Slate and others writing about it. So, I went to check out the video and got this instead:
Yup. Thanks, Universal Music and copyright for taking down something that was getting this song more attention. Of course, multiple other copies appear to have shown up in response (not all identical, but all using versions of the same footage). Those are all up as I post this, but I imagine they're likely to disappear soon too.
It makes you wonder what's the point here? Yes, legally, Universal/Taylor Swift may have the legal right to pull the video down (though, some could make a reasonable fair use argument), but it seems pretty futile. Here are people having fun with her music, doing something of their own free will to get it more attention (I hadn't heard the song at all before this), and then it gets pulled down, because copyright.
In many ways, this is the antithesis of how music worked for ages. Music was always about people sharing and building on the works of others. Someone would create a song, and others would take it, resing it, adapt it, change it, mix it up with other things. That's how culture works. But not so much in an era with strict copyright laws and automated takedown systems. What a shame.
*Charlie Koncher has since re-uploaded the video originally posted to his Facebook page. You can view the original video below.
Somehow the record labels continue to fight what isn’t worth fighting. The video wasn’t making money, it wasn’t infringing on the artist or the copyright owners. I wonder if the 3 majors left will ever stop fighting their fans and listeners.
funny this is taylor swift actually tweeted a link to this video on her own twitter so….
“In many ways, this is the antithesis of how music worked for ages. Music was always about people sharing and building on the works of others. Someone would create a song, and others would take it, resing it, adapt it, change it, mix it up with other things. That’s how culture works. But not so much in an era with strict copyright laws and automated takedown systems.”
Could a Television program take that song and add it to their program and create a video around it without clearance and a license? Just askin’
If you don’t have a Elephone G4 SIM card, contact your wireless provider to get the right type of SIM card based on the device you are switching to. They can also help verify that you are set up with the right data plan for your new device.
Hm, why bring TechDirt articles here?
What’s next – Pirate Bay ads?