« Upward Spiral 14: Interview With Joey Flores Of Earbits, Internet Radio Royalties, Startups & More | Main | A Better Widget: Why Aren't Online Music Services Music-Friendly? »


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Interesting points and as part time music blogger, I'd have to agree. If people who submit follow these tips, they have a better chance of being heard and possibly posted.


Good list, Clyde. To add to #2, I search for similar bands on blog aggregators like The Hype Machine and Elbo.ws. Blogs that are listed in those directories produce coverage that is more likely to spread to other sources.

Alex Day

You forgot "don't let your fans help".



I'm a music critic so I can add a few things to this topic based on my +10 yrs of experience but my post was not written for any discussion that much, just expressing my views.
I review heavy guitar driven songs, EPs or albums, from digital files and streams while CDs are not important to me because I don't want people pay any additionally shipping fees. It's the digital age & bands should sell these CDs to fans instead.

First of all, any high quality review has 2 purposes - an individual judgment and recommendation/promotion values which usually lead readers to buy a song/EP/album, or not. A good review means a story to tell.

1. A band looking for reviews should read some examples of reviews to be sure about their value & a reviewer's skills either. Some people 'feel' any kind of music, some can write smoothly about black metal and some get disgusted hearing the first scream. Testimonials are important.

2. If a reviewer gives a rating which is constantly low (unless music received is constantly that bad, the reviewer is not selective, or is not a specialist in a genre a band represents!), it's not any good deal for a musician to waste his/her time, money or hopes to get any reliable judgment.

3. Many bloggers/reviewers prefer to receive as many CDs as possible because they are 'music collectors' while they do not have enough of time to review them all or they offer low quality reviews = 60% talking about themselves and 40% about the band & their music!

4. A reviewer needs to be in a 'mood' to provide a good writing. When one works over a song or album for 1-3 hrs, his/her brain will be activated to remember the sound, hooks or whatever and it needs some time to 'clean' one's brain. Switching between albums, producing mass-reviews in a hurry is never good.

5. What personally pisses me off the most:
a) a lot of bands (and labels!) do not read requirements given on a magazine/blog/via email but they blindly give an instant access to files or send CDs without doing any research. This causes a lot of misunderstanding!,

b) a band/manager must ask a reviewer or magazine owner if he/she is interested in receiving a newsletter. Most of 'PR specialists' and bands steal emails and attach these to some Reverbnation or Fanbridge systems to spam people (because they were paid to do the job or they want to help a band only). These emails always land up in my spam box since I didn't request them or agreed to receive either,

c) do not attach music files to an email without being asked for. Not everybody uses a high-speed internet or owns a 4TB hard drive to store your attachments. Instead, a press kit (pdf) with links to the most representative pages/profiles (SoundCloud or Reverbnation) are welcome instead.
It takes me usually 15-20 min. per band to make a final decision if I'm interested in a coverage or not, yet I've a schedule, a good ear for music and personal taste ;)

6. Bands should choose these magazines which have a strong no-piracy policy. Reviewers should never share any music they got for a review while most of them do that without permission, same about podcasters. If they have any Terms of Use or Privacy Policy, it should be mentioned there.

7. If you sent a request for a review and got no answer during 2-5 weeks, send a reminder. If you still didn't get any reply, you've found the wrong magazine = not interested in reviewing your music. Gmail or Yahoo filters can automatically mark a message as spam so if it happened to your email, a reviewer may have not seen your message yet.

8. On the final, unpleasant for some note, reviewing music, books etc. takes a lot of time, needs skills, planning and understanding a genre and goals of a songwriter/author. If a professional asks you for money for such a writing, don't come up with an attitude such as 'we want you to write about us for free so we can sell our music because we have a lot of other expenses/because you love music etc.' since you'll make a fool of yourself. A reviewer has the same/similar bills to pay like you, expenses to cover yet they do their work as much involved as you make your music. Keep in mind, there's also a copyright (authorship) & a license for a promo or commercial purposes involved if musicians want to make money on such a review (and they surely do if it's a positive one = album recommendation).

When you're hired, you are paid for your work, that's the law.
Try to go to your boss to tell him/her you're going to work 8hrs a day for free during the next month. Certainly it's a great deal for your boss having a slave to abuse but a disaster for your own future and a making yourself a huge disrespect for your skills as well (considering you provide high quality reviews to help the bands, not a blabla thing to show off with your own ego!)

I hope that helps.

Clyde Smith

Help is one thing. Mobbing up is another!

Clyde Smith

Good call.

Clyde Smith


Christopher Wilson

#3 is very true. I recently sent a CD for review to a music critic I had not previously contacted and was expecting to get ignored. But, in the comments about my CD, he mentioned that "so and so at such and such" site was a friend and had written about my previous albums, so he'd give it a listen. I'd like to think he would have listened to it anyway, but it helps to have connections or previous cred.


A good tip would be to get fans to help find the blogs and submit the music, I love it when some of the fans tell me about the artists, by the way if any bands/artists reading this would like to send me their music to check out at makewayforbands@hotmail.com I will have a look at their music and may even do a post on them if I enjoy them, my blog is makewayforbands.blogspot.co.uk


Wow! Great information.

Emilie H.


Great advice

The comments to this entry are closed.


Musician & Music Industry Resources